Skip to content
    Film
    group
    Drama

    Billy and Scott's 'I Want You at First' Scene

    from Moneyball

    Written by Steven Zaillian & Aaron Sorkin

    Moneyball

    2 min · 3 characters · Any gender · 35-45

    Billy Beane and Ron Washington visit Scott Hatteberg to convince the injured catcher to reinvent himself as a first baseman for the Oakland A's.

    Start a free 7-day trial — 5 downloads a day, unlimited when Pro begins

    Rehearse this scene
    Rehearse on your terms

    Choose your role and voices for the other characters. Run the scene at your own pace.

    Scene PreviewExcerpt — subscribe to read full scene

    BILLY

    You've played catcher your whole life?

    SCOTT

    Since I was 8.

    BILLY

    How's the elbow?

    SCOTT

    Good. Real good. It's great.

    Beat

    I can't throw at all.

    BILLY

    Yeah, don't worry about it. You've thrown your last baseball from behind the plate. I want you at first.

    End of preview. Continue with Pro below.

    7 days freeYour next rehearsal starts here

    Found your next scene? Make it yours.

    Start your free trial and read Billy and Scott's 'I Want You at First' Scene in full, with access to 9,000+ monologues and scenes to explore next.

    • Read the full scene and explore the library
    • Download your script in a clean, printable format
    • Take it into rehearsal with the Script Reader
    Casting Types
    Get Feedback
    Coming Soon

    Want expert coaching on this scene?

    Browse our curated list of acting coaches, dialect specialists, and more.

    Find a Coach

    Need representation?

    Browse verified agents and casting directors in our directory.

    Scene Notes & Audition Tips

    5 sections
    About This Scene

    In this contemporary dramatic scene written by Steven Zaillian & Aaron Sorkin, baseball executive Billy Beane and coach Ron Washington pay a late-night visit to injured catcher Scott Hatteberg. Facing the premature end of his career due to a severe arm injury, Scott is offered an unexpected lifeline when Billy proposes an unorthodox position change to first base. The scene balances high-stakes career negotiation with grounded realism, highlighting a pivotal crossroads where an athlete must confront his physical limitations and risk total reinvention.

    Character Analysis

    Billy operates as a decisive authority figure and unorthodox mentor, displaying razor-sharp focus and relentless persuasion while refusing to indulge defeatism. Scott embodies an everyman athlete at a devastating career crossroads, wrestling with vulnerability, the loss of his professional identity, and the genuine terror of public failure. Washington acts as an earthy, pragmatic counterweight, providing blunt honesty that grounds Billy's visionary optimism in stark reality.

    Why This Works for Auditions

    The dialogue offers rapid, rhythmically precise exchanges that demand exceptional timing, active listening, and vocal dexterity. Each role possesses distinct motivations and clear viewpoints, allowing performers to showcase layered subtext beneath fast-moving conversational banter. It is particularly effective for group showcases or dramatic scene study because the emotional tension remains tethered to authentic professional and personal stakes.

    Best Suited For

    This piece is exceptionally well suited for actors aged thirty-five to forty-five targeting casting types such as the authoritative leader, charismatic mentor, or vulnerable everyman. It serves as prime material for agent showcases, self-tapes with readers, and advanced scene study classes focusing on status transactions and brisk comedic timing within a drama.

    Performance Tips

    Maintain the brisk, musical tempo demanded by the writing without rushing past the underlying emotional beats. The actor playing Scott must allow the shock and defensive embarrassment of physical vulnerability to land truthfully before absorbing the gravity of the offer. Meanwhile, Billy and Washington must establish their contrasting dynamic immediately, letting Washington's deadpan skepticism bounce naturally against Billy's forward-driving momentum.

    No ratings yet
    Sign in to rate