Bart Nickerson

Act I. Natalie visits her former best friend Kevyn at the police station after twenty-two years of silence, presenting him with a box of shared teenage memorabilia. While Kevyn confronts her about her sudden disappearance decades ago, he realizes she is likely following a twelve-step recovery program and asks for a dinner date as a way to make amends.

Natalie confronts Shauna in a minivan with a friend's autopsy report, suggesting that a supposed overdose was actually murder. Shauna desperately tries to maintain her suburban facade and dismisses Natalie's claims as addict-fueled paranoia, revealing the deep-seated trauma and secrets shared between the two survivors.

In the aftermath of a plane crash, Travis returns to his father's grave to retrieve a valuable family heirloom. Natalie tries to stop him from committing the macabre act, leading to a physical and emotional confrontation that reveals Travis's deep-seated insecurities and desperation.