Skip to content
    Tv
    duologue
    Drama

    Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene

    Andy and Loguidice's scene from Defending Jacob, season 1 episode 1

    Written by Mark Bomback

    Defending Jacob

    2 min · 2 characters · Any gender · 35-45

    During a grand jury hearing, Andy Barber is interrogated by Loguidice about the forensic details and lack of evidence in a local murder case.

    Start a free 7-day trial — 5 downloads a day, unlimited when Pro begins

    Rehearse this scene
    Rehearse on your terms

    Choose your role and voices for the other characters. Run the scene at your own pace.

    Scene PreviewExcerpt — subscribe to read full scene

    ANDY

    What about the knife?

    LOGUIDICE

    You explained that Ben Rifkin had been stabbed three times in the chest. Could you describe the angle of entry?

    ANDY

    The weapon was driven straight in and jerked straight out again.

    LOGUIDICE

    So the motion was a thrusting motion? Like a bayonet?

    ANDY

    I suppose, yes.

    End of preview. Continue with Pro below.

    7 days freeYour next rehearsal starts here

    Found your next scene? Make it yours.

    Start your free trial and read Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene in full, with access to 10,000 monologues and scenes to explore next.

    • Read the full scene and explore the library
    • Download your script in a clean, printable format
    • Take it into rehearsal with the Script Reader
    Start my 7-day free trial

    Loading local pricing · Cancel anytime

    Still deciding?

    Keep this scene in your free shortlist. No card needed.

    View plans and pricing

    Christmas gift? Give a year of Pro, 15% off. Paid once, nothing renews.
    Casting Types
    Get Feedback
    Coming Soon

    Want expert coaching on this scene?

    Browse our curated list of acting coaches, dialect specialists, and more.

    Find a Coach

    Need representation?

    Browse verified agents and casting directors in our directory.

    About Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene

    How long is Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene?
    About 2 minutes performed aloud.
    Which characters are in Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene?
    It is a duologue for Andy and Loguidice, with a playing age of 35–45, open to actors of any gender.
    Is Andy and Loguidice's 'What About the Knife' Scene good for auditions?
    It suits agent showcases, self-tapes and general practice.

    Scene Notes & Audition Tips

    5 sections
    About This Scene

    Written by Mark Bomback for the television drama Defending Jacob, this intense contemporary duologue unfolds inside a grand jury hearing. Andy Barber sits in the witness chair, subjected to a pointed examination by Loguidice regarding the forensic specifics and the conspicuous absence of evidence surrounding a local murder. The encounter is charged with unspoken history and procedural gamesmanship, as both figures navigate the delicate environment of the courtroom.

    Character Analysis

    Andy is a capable professional forced into an uncomfortable defensive posture, answering questions with measured technical precision while harboring clear animosity toward his interrogator. He carefully weighs every statement to avoid yielding ground or compromising his position. Loguidice is calculating, sharp, and theatrical in a subtle way, playing to the room while attempting to expose holes, weaknesses, or oversights in the investigation.

    Why This Works for Auditions

    This scene serves as an excellent vehicle for actors who want to demonstrate precision, high-stakes restraint, and mastery of subtext. The dialogue moves briskly through factual exposition, requiring both performers to keep the emotional conflict alive beneath rigid legal professionalism. Because the stakes are high but expressed through disciplined verbal sparring, casting directors can clearly evaluate an actor's timing, active listening, and ability to project authority under pressure.

    Best Suited For

    The piece is ideally tailored for performers aged 35 to 45 who fit casting types such as lawyers, investigators, authority figures, and sophisticated leading performers. It functions exceptionally well for self-tapes, agent showcases, and drama class work where partners need a focused, two-minute confrontation grounded in contemporary realism.

    Performance Tips

    Actors should avoid treating the technical details and forensic terminology as mere data, instead using each fact as an offensive jab or defensive shield. Keep physical movements disciplined and purposeful, reflecting the formal setting while letting eye contact and micro-shifts in posture signal the underlying hostility. Pay strict attention to pacing, ensuring the interruptions and subtle corrections land with deliberate intent rather than accidental overlap.

    No ratings yet
    Sign in to rate