Skip to content
    Tv
    duologue
    Drama

    Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene

    Dan and Andy's scene from Defending Jacob, season 1 episode 1

    Written by Mark Bomback

    Defending Jacob

    2 min · 2 characters · Any gender · 35-45

    A grieving father, Dan, confronts Assistant District Attorney Andy Barber about the nature of evil and the desperate need for closure after his son's

    Start a free 7-day trial — 5 downloads a day, unlimited when Pro begins

    Rehearse this scene
    Rehearse on your terms

    Choose your role and voices for the other characters. Run the scene at your own pace.

    Scene PreviewExcerpt — subscribe to read full scene

    DAN

    The thing I can’t get past is... why did this guy do it?

    ANDY

    Dan, it’s not a good idea to--

    DAN

    No just, hear me out. When you call to update us, it’s always the details: the evidence, the court procedures. But all I really care about is why. Ben was so good. So good. Who could feel that kind of, of rage against him? Tell me. What separates these…

    End of preview. Continue with Pro below.

    7 days freeYour next rehearsal starts here

    Found your next scene? Make it yours.

    Start your free trial and read Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene in full, with access to 10,000 monologues and scenes to explore next.

    • Read the full scene and explore the library
    • Download your script in a clean, printable format
    • Take it into rehearsal with the Script Reader
    Start my 7-day free trial

    Loading local pricing · Cancel anytime

    Still deciding?

    Keep this scene in your free shortlist. No card needed.

    View plans and pricing

    Christmas gift? Give a year of Pro, 15% off. Paid once, nothing renews.
    Casting Types
    Get Feedback
    Coming Soon

    Want expert coaching on this scene?

    Browse our curated list of acting coaches, dialect specialists, and more.

    Find a Coach

    Need representation?

    Browse verified agents and casting directors in our directory.

    About Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene

    How long is Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene?
    About 2 minutes performed aloud.
    Which characters are in Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene?
    It is a duologue for Dan and Andy, with a playing age of 35–45, open to actors of any gender.
    Is Dan and Andy's 'Why Did This Guy Do It' Scene good for auditions?
    It suits agent showcases, self-tapes and general practice.

    Scene Notes & Audition Tips

    5 sections
    About This Scene

    In this quiet yet devastating contemporary duologue written by Mark Bomback, a grieving parent confronts Assistant District Attorney Andy Barber inside the bedroom of a murdered child. Rather than focusing on investigative procedure or legal technicalities, Dan desperately probes the psychological motives of violent criminals, seeking answers that the justice system rarely provides. Andy finds himself caught between his duty as an officer of the law and his instincts as a fellow parent, trying to offer comfort while enduring the crushing weight of Dan's sorrow.

    Character Analysis

    Dan is an Everyman consumed by raw grief, bewilderment, and an aching need for closure in the wake of an incomprehensible tragedy. Dan is not hostile, but deeply shaken, searching Andy's eyes for insight into what drives people to commit horrific acts and whether surviving families ever truly heal. Andy functions as an authority figure whose professional boundaries are severely strained by Dan's vulnerability. As a father himself, Andy feels intense empathy and unease, forced to measure every word so as not to shatter Dan's fragile emotional state.

    Why This Works for Auditions

    This scene offers two compelling acting tracks that showcase restraint, rich subtext, and high emotional stakes without resorting to melodramatic outbursts. For the actor playing Dan, it provides an exceptional vehicle to explore the physical reality of grief, shifting between fragile composure and desperate inquiry. For Andy, the scene tests active listening and internal conflict, requiring the actor to convey profound compassion, guilt, and professional caution purely through quiet reactions and measured pacing.

    Best Suited For

    Running approximately two minutes, this dramatic scene is ideal for actors in the 35 to 45 age range preparing self-tapes, agent showcases, or advanced scene study work. It is particularly well matched for performers targeting grounded dramatic television roles, such as grieving parents, law enforcement figures, prosecutors, and everyday characters navigating intense personal loss.

    Performance Tips

    Actors portraying Dan should avoid playing generalized sorrow, focusing instead on the practical pursuit of an answer that might bring peace. The actor playing Andy must stay fully engaged in the pauses, letting the burden of Dan's questions register physically before responding with careful precision. Keep the vocal delivery conversational and intimate, allowing the heavy atmosphere of the space to dictate the rhythm of the exchange.

    No ratings yet
    Sign in to rate