CATHERINE. I'm PARANOID?
HAL. Wait.
HAL. Good night.
CATHERINE. Wait, your coat.
CATHERINE. You think I should go JOGGING?
Proof — The Machinery — Proof
Catherine confronts Hal after discovering he has taken a notebook belonging to her deceased father. The confrontation escalates as Catherine accuses him of theft, but Hal reveals the notebook contains a poignant entry about her, written by her father.
Format: Duologue · Genre: Drama · Source: Proof · Author: David Auburn · Characters: CATHERINE, HAL
About This Scene
This contemporary duologue from David Auburn's play Proof is a highly charged confrontation between Catherine and Hal. The scene begins with Catherine discovering Hal in possession of her deceased father's notebook, leading to an intense accusation of theft. As their argument escalates, Hal attempts to reveal the true significance of the notebook's contents, shifting the dynamic from anger to a profound emotional revelation concerning Catherine's relationship with her father.
Character Analysis
Catherine, aged 18-25, is presented as vulnerable yet intensely dramatic, struggling with grief and a deep sense of protectiveness over her father's legacy. Her accusations against Hal stem from a place of profound mistrust and feeling violated, quickly escalating to rage. Hal, also 18-25, embodies a young professional type, driven by a genuine, if somewhat clumsy, desire to convey an important discovery, navigating Catherine’s emotional volatility with a mix of frustration and earnestness.
Why This Works for Auditions
This scene is a fantastic choice for auditions due to its immediate conflict and clear emotional arc. Both characters experience significant shifts, offering actors a substantial range to explore, from explosive anger and desperation to a moment of quiet, powerful discovery. The dialogue is sharp, realistic, and provides ample opportunity for actors to demonstrate their ability to listen, react, and sustain intense emotional states within a duologue format.
Best Suited For
This duologue is best suited for actors aged 18-25 looking to showcase their ability to perform intense, dramatic material. Its exploration of grief, trust, and family makes it particularly effective for those who can portray vulnerable, yet fierce, characters. It's an excellent choice for drama school auditions, self-tapes, general practice, and competitions where a dynamic and emotionally rich contemporary piece is required.
Performance Tips
When performing this scene, focus on the power dynamics and how they shift. For Catherine, track the intensity of her rage and how it breaks down into a profound emotional moment of recognition. For Hal, concentrate on his attempts to breakthrough Catherine's anger, showing the urgency and sincerity of his revelation amidst her accusations. Pay close attention to breathwork to fuel the high emotional stakes, and allow the weight of the father's words to create a palpable shift in the atmosphere.