Skip to content
    Film
    duologue
    Drama

    The Puppy Argument

    Laney and Bruce's scene from I Smile Back

    Written by Paige Dylan & Amy Koppelman

    I Smile Back

    2 min · 2 characters · Any gender · 25-35 (also 35-45)

    Laney expresses her nihilistic fears to Bruce, arguing that they shouldn't keep a puppy because the inevitable grief of its death is too much to bear.

    Start a free 7-day trial — 5 downloads a day, unlimited when Pro begins

    Rehearse this scene
    Rehearse on your terms

    Choose your role and voices for the other characters. Run the scene at your own pace.

    Scene PreviewExcerpt — subscribe to read full scene

    LANEY

    We gotta get rid of Bingo.

    LANEY

    Bruce, I’m serious we can’t keep him.

    BRUCE

    It’s just a puppy Laney. All kids get a puppy. Why can’t our kids have a God damn puppy? Why does it have to be such a big deal? Why does everything have to be such a big deal.

    LANEY

    Because puppies turn into dogs and dogs get old and die. What’s a dog live, ten years?

    End of preview. Continue with Pro below.

    7 days freeYour next rehearsal starts here

    Found your next scene? Make it yours.

    Start your free trial and read The Puppy Argument in full, with access to 10,000 monologues and scenes to explore next.

    • Read the full scene and explore the library
    • Download your script in a clean, printable format
    • Take it into rehearsal with the Script Reader
    Start my 7-day free trial

    Loading local pricing · Cancel anytime

    Still deciding?

    Keep this scene in your free shortlist. No card needed.

    View plans and pricing

    Christmas gift? Give a year of Pro, 15% off. Paid once, nothing renews.
    Casting Types
    Get Feedback
    Coming Soon

    Want expert coaching on this scene?

    Browse our curated list of acting coaches, dialect specialists, and more.

    Find a Coach

    Need representation?

    Browse verified agents and casting directors in our directory.

    About The Puppy Argument

    How long is The Puppy Argument?
    About 2 minutes performed aloud.
    Which characters are in The Puppy Argument?
    It is a duologue for Laney and Bruce, with a playing age of 25–35 or 35–45, open to actors of any gender.
    Is The Puppy Argument good for auditions?
    It suits agent showcases, self-tapes and general practice.

    Scene Notes & Audition Tips

    5 sections
    About This Scene

    Written by Paige Dylan & Amy Koppelman for the contemporary drama film I Smile Back, this two-minute duologue captures an intense, emotionally charged conversation between married partners Laney and Bruce. What begins as an everyday household disagreement over keeping a family puppy quickly spirals into a profound confrontation with mortality and depression. As Laney articulates her nihilistic worldview, the scene exposes the fragile emotional foundations of their marriage and parenting life.

    Character Analysis

    Laney is consumed by severe existential dread and acute vulnerability, projecting her personal terror of loss onto her children's future. Her arguments stem from a desperate urge to avoid inevitable pain, revealing a woman drowning in hopelessness despite her domestic surroundings. Bruce functions as a grounded, pragmatic foil who initially expects a normal parenting debate. As the dialogue progresses, his exasperation gives way to gentle, watchful caution when he realizes that his spouse is experiencing a severe internal crisis.

    Why This Works for Auditions

    This piece offers casting professionals a sharp demonstration of how actors manage subtext and complex tonal shifts under two minutes. The argument avoids predictable shouting matches, instead relying on psychological tension, nuanced listening, and shared history. It gives both performers the chance to navigate raw grief, marital intimacy, and unresolved distress while maintaining absolute realism and emotional restraint.

    Best Suited For

    This material is tailored for actors in their late twenties to mid-thirties who align with Leading Lady, Leading Man, Parent, Intense, or Vulnerable casting types. Because of its quiet intensity and compact running time, it serves as an excellent vehicle for self-tape submissions, agent showcases, and advanced general practice in contemporary drama.

    Performance Tips

    Resist the temptation to treat this conversation as a standard fight; the tragedy of the scene lies in how deeply these characters care for one another. Laney must deliver her bleak philosophy with sincere, terrifying logic rather than manufactured tears or theatrical anger. Bruce needs to carefully track the transition from annoyance to protective alarm, using physical gestures to bridge the emotional divide. Pay careful attention to the beats of silence, allowing the unspoken fears in the room to land with full weight before speaking.

    No ratings yet
    Sign in to rate